Let me pause from my usual
Your Daily Sarah routine of the last weeks. I want to discuss a weightier topic today with the readership.
When you are a foreigner, like I still am in many respects despite my flag-waving, you are actually "taught" certain things about Americans:
- People in the street, who are barely literate themselves, will scoff at Americans for their lack of culture and geographical knowledge
- Academics in our schools and Universities will present American history in as predatory a light as possible
- News media and famous intellectuals of the day will, with infinite Schadenfreude, rail about the downhill nature of the American state
Do they want America to fail? Yes, some foreigners do. But many, many more do not.
Even the ones who do, wish little actual harm to the American people -- they just want America the nation to be more "like others". In short, they wish to end American exceptionalism, built they believe on religion, military power and above all, capitalism. As they see it, this triumverate is hopelessly out of date, barely past the Industrial Revolution. The modern response for any clear-thinking country should be securalism, peace, and socialism, but America just doesn't "listen".
But it's more than that. Their unease is almost animistic in scope -- I believe that for some people, good comes in measured doses. Call it the
Gold Standard of Karma.
To some people, it's as if America has hoarded most of the goodness available in the world. It "prevents" others from advancing. That is an affront to many people, some of whom consider themselves to be far better, as a nation and as a people, to be beneficiaries of Fate's bounty.
Consider these facts.
Few nation-states have access to two oceans. No nation was able to carve an inland empire and populate it not just coastally, but inside the interior, like America has since 1620. Brazil doesn't even come close. Even States which would be uninhabitable in other countries, due to extremes in weather, function at 100% normalcy (such as Alaska and Arizona, coincidentally enough...). The 50 States are all solvent, at that, contributing to the common weal. Lastly, despite very real structural problems, like slavery, segregation, and runaway markets, the American state sails on 232 years after its birth whereas other republics are in their fifth or more incarnations.
Why? Why?
The American way of life is the reason.
When I came to this country, no one had to tell me to love it. I did that on my own. I embraced this country knowing the realities I had seen elsewhere were exponentially worse than anything existing in America, even in crime and drug-use.
I did it despite having come from a vibrant, successful country, where I had a wonderful road paved ahead of me due to my academic accomplishments and social background. I chose uncertainty, but the choice wasn't fraught with nervousness. I was coming to America, after all. If bad things have to happen, it's better that they happen here. Recovery is quicker.
Part of the reason recovery is quicker is that most Americans know that their country "works". How exactly, why exactly, by what miracle exactly, no one really seems to know. But it does.
So knowing this, they do small things that help it along. They love their flag. They revere their Constitution. They have a strong sense of civic duty and volunteerism. They join up to fight for her in droves, out of conviction, not because they have a mandatory military call-up when they turn 18. Yes, they are willing to risk their lives, even in times of war.
And, above all, they hold this truth to be self-evident: that
America is a good country.
It's a self-judgement from a hyper-critical people.
They arrived at that conclusion at the knees of their grandparents, who taught them about pogroms, vainglorious absolute monarchs and arbitrary Martial Law. That isn't America. That was never America. That cannot be America.
This American ethos to make things work acts as self-fulfilling prophecy. They go out and find a solution, and then execute it, each generation adding its own twist to the solution.
They do this because whatever faults lie endemic in this nation, America was conceived as an oasis of reason and even today, acts as a springboard to greater freedom for millions of people who still wish to come here. The stakes couldn't be any higher, not just for Americans, but for the world, if only they'd be honest about it.
A really odd thing happened in the 1970s: some Americans were able to insinuate themselves into the country's narrative of itself. These people have a different view of America. For them, the cracks are craters, and the fissures are chasms. The intensity of their feeling was met full on by a cultural pushback, and we are seeing these two collide real-time in 2008.
This is the political part of his essay, that I'm sure you knew was coming.
Because it is my contention that, at the same time, the economic system, political system, and social system of America is undergoing cataclysmic stress.
If the Revolution was Act 1, the Civil War was Act 2, the Gilded Age was Act 3, the Great Depression Act 4, and World War II ushered in Act 5, then we are witnessing Act 6, not in 2001, as many people thought, but in 2008.
It is our own mini clash of American civilisations.On one side, you have traditionalists, people who believe in the free-market and in the strong world leadership America has projected since 1945. They embody that in their own life choices, too.
On the other, you have those who have suffered from both the social and economic side of this America, and though they may personally have overcome them, they believe America leaves too many people behind. If they believe in the free-market system, they also see other systems which are far more equitable, and wish to emulate them.
There is no "give" in either of these mindsets. One is as resolute as the other, each imbued in thinking its way is right. The first because it continues the spirit of America, the second because it believes it will better America.
The people who represent these two modalities will alter the future of America forever. Make no mistake about that. America has reached a point in its history where the choices they make today will define the way it looks in the next 50 years.
Let us, Americans and non-Americans alike, stop pretending with each other that we do not know all of this is at stake.
Let's stop using racism, agism, snobbism as excuses for pin-pricks to our egos.
Face the matter squarely -- there is no middle way in 2008. It's either The Old or The New, and THIS is why the election today is still so close.
America is still deciding.
RelatedRoger L. Simon's Article On Why Bill Clinton Is Not On BoardAmerica Will Lose Superpower Status Says German MinisterDeep-Seated Racism To BlameIt's The Second Amendment, StupidLabels: Common Man, Generational Divide, Ideological Impasse, Matters Racial, US Presidential Election, USA